Goyard: Love Me or Leave Me? A Luxury Brand Faces a Crisis of Identity

Goyard: The Myth, the Machine, and the Market

For years, Goyard has been the epitome of luxury. Those iconic canvas bags, with their intricate Y-shaped patterns, have been on every fashionista's wishlist. But things have changed. Goyard is no longer the exclusive, handmade brand it once was. 

Src: colorandchic.com

src: sothebys.com

Goyard has always maintained a low-key brand image. They don’t hire celebrity endorsers or engage in extensive advertising campaigns. You won’t see their ads on TV or social media. Additionally, Goyard has no online sales channels or authorized retailers. The only way to purchase their bags is by visiting a physical store. This unique sales model not only maintains the brand’s exclusivity but also creates a sense of mystery, attracting consumers who seek unique products.

In recent years, I've observed a surge in the popularity of Goyard bags. During my recent trips to Singapore and Seoul, Goyard was by far the most spotted luxury handbags on the streets, outshining even Louis Vuitton and Chanel. Given this increased visibility, I'm curious to know if Goyard's loss of exclusivity could potentially diminish its appeal.

The Birth of a Legend

src: thevogueagent.com

Goyard's journey began with the innovative use of a canvas material that resembled leather but was actually made from cotton and flax. This material, developed by Edmond Goyard in 1892, was waterproof and incredibly durable. The Y-shaped pattern, a distinctive feature of the brand, was a tribute to the Goyard family name. Initially, the pattern was applied by hand, using a technique known as point-à-point, which involved meticulously dotting the canvas with small,colored points. This painstaking process, combined with the unique canvas material, made Goyard bags highly sought-after and exclusive.

The Machine Age

In the early 2000s, Goyard made a significant departure from its traditional methods. To meet the increasing demand for its products, the brand decided to replace the time-consuming point-à-point technique with a machine-printing process.This shift allowed for faster production and more consistent results. While the machine-printed bags retained the iconic Y-shaped pattern, they lacked the artisanal touch that had previously defined the brand.

Consequences and Controversy

The transition to machine-printed canvas had both positive and negative consequences. On the one hand, it led to a surge in sales as the brand became more accessible to a wider audience. However, it also raised concerns about the brand's authenticity and the quality of its products. As the Goyard name became more widely recognized, counterfeits began to flood the market, further tarnishing the brand's reputation.

Counterfeit Goyard Saint Louis Has Flooded Street Markets

Well-Made Bag?

In addition to counterfeit issues, more and more customers began to notice the quality problems with the Goyard bags. Complaints included fading colors, stiff and uncomfortable straps, and a perceived lack of durability. These issues were a stark contrast to the high standards that Goyard had previously set.

Faded Goyardine Print

Worn corners are a very common problem with Goyard bags

Cracks on the wax of the handle is another common problem

Some complain the color on the straps can bleed in hot and humid climate

The Current Landscape

Despite the challenges it has faced, Goyard remains a desirable brand. The brand's iconic status, coupled with its limited availability, has helped maintain its appeal. In recent years, Goyard has increased its prices significantly, further emphasizing its luxury positioning. However, this has also made it more difficult for consumers to obtain popular styles.

Conclusion

Goyard's journey from a small, artisanal brand to a global luxury label has been marked by both triumphs and setbacks.The brand's decision to embrace machine-printing was a strategic one that helped to meet the demands of a growing market. However, it also led to a dilution of its unique selling proposition. While Goyard remains a coveted brand, its future success will depend on its ability to balance tradition with innovation and to maintain the high standards of quality that have always been associated with its name.